LA News Release, "New Race Relations Law Misconceived and Potentially Damaging" (October 2002)

Share this

In Association with the Libertarian International

London, Wednesday, 30 October 2002
For Immediate Release

Contact Details: David Carr, 07951 777307

"New Race Relations Law Misconceived and Potentially Damaging", Says Free Market and Civil Liberties Think Tank

The proposal by the Home Office, to extend the terms of the Race Relations Act to cover employment in and around the home, is both misconceived and potentially damaging.

Speaking Today in London, David Carr, a practising lawyer and Libertarian Alliance Executive Committee Member, said:

"The government's decision to force the equal opportunities laws on householders seeking to employ nannies, cleaners or gardeners cuts a swathe through the meritorious distinction between the private and the public and places upon those householders an added dimension of risk in a process that is already fraught with potential pitfalls and dangers.
"This alone would be bad enough but the effects will be exarcerbated by the proposal that, in the event of a claim of discrimination being made, the Common Law tradition of the burden of proof being on the Claimant, be reversed.
"This means, that once the Claimant has made a prima facie case, it will up to the Defendant to prove that he or she was not racist. It is always decidedly difficult to prove a negative and any putative employers so accused face the prospect of a ruinous law-suit which they stand very little chance of being able to successfully defend.
"Not to mention that blanket powers to accuse without the burden of consequence are a gilt-edged opportunity for charlatans and rogues to make malicious claims (or threaten the same) with a view to obtaining money or other favours by dint of their menace.
"Presumably, the motive behind this proposal is to promote better race relations in this country. For sure, a laudable goal but one that will not be achieved by this measure which will, in fact, tend to have the very contrary effect.  It means that home employers are being invited to view Black or Asian people not just as fellow human beings but as harbingers of potential bankruptcy.
"The pursuit of racial harmony should not be an excuse for the government to so imperil otherwise law-abiding citizens nor traduce long-established Common Law safeguards from which we all benefit regardless of our racial background."


Note(s) to Editors

Dr Sean Gabb is the Director of the Libertarian Alliance. He is the author of ten novels and ten other books, plus about a million words of journalism. He can be contacted for further comment on 07956 472 199 or by email at

His latest novel, The Break, has been nominated for the 2015 Prometheus Award.

His recent book, Freedom of Speech in England: Its Present State and Likely Prospects, is a defence of freedom of speech without exceptions. 

Or his book, Cultural Revolution, Culture War: How Conservatives Lost England, and How to Get It Back, explains how its current ruling class has turned England into a totalitarian police state, and how this ruling class can be overthrown and utterly destroyed.

Or another of his books, Smoking, Class and the Legitimation of Power, explains how the current "war" on smoking has nothing to do with making individuals healthy, but everything to do with enhancing the power of a totalitarian ruling class, and enriching its relevant client groups.

You can see other books by Sean Gabb here.

Extended Contact Details

The Libertarian Alliance is Britain's most radical free market and civil liberties policy institute. It has published over 800 articles, pamphlets and books in support of freedom and against statism in all its forms. These are freely available at

Our postal address is

The Libertarian Alliance
Suite 35
2 Lansdowne Row
Tel: 07956 472 199